Mindhorn directed by Sean Foley – review by Calum Maclean

Mindhorn
Directed by Sean Foley
Written by Julian Barratt and Simon Farnaby
Cast – Julian Barratt, Essie Davis, Russell Tovey, Andrea Riseborough, Simon Farnaby, Steve Coogan
It’s always a pleasure to see an idea as brilliantly daft as Mindhorn make it into mainstream cinema, but it’s even more enjoyable when that concept is carried through with as much commitment and authenticity as it is here. The film tells the story of Richard Thorncroft, once lauded as the sex symbol hero of 80’s tv hit Mindhorn, now a balding, paunchy has been, debasing himself at auditions for roles he has no business attempting. Fortunately for Richard, a deranged killer on the Isle of Man is convinced that Mindhorn is a real detective and will only negotiate with him, leading the police to reluctantly invite Throncroft back to the Island to reprise his role, and confront the figures from his past he abandoned in pursuit of fleeting fame.
This film fits perfectly into the British comedy tradition of delusional pomposity, containing elements of Alan Partridge and Garth Merenghi’s Darkplace, as well as an affectionate parody of the naffness of 1980’s tv detectives like Bergerac and Lovejoy. The detail put into the Mindhorn character, with his eye that can “literally see the truth”, shoe donning ritual and health endangering merchandise, all contribute to a hilarious realism, as does the Isle of Man setting for some underwhelming attempts at action heroics from Throncroft.
The cast are uniformly brilliant, from Riseborough’s exasperated detective, to Farnaby and Coogan’s smug antagonists. However, the central trio of Barratt, Davis and Tovey deserve particular praise for the balance of comedy and pathos in their performances. Barratt is excellent throughout, giving Thorncroft just the right level of dickishness to justify some of the hostility he encounters, but communicating through his manic smile and pleading eyes a level of desperation that keeps the audience on his side. Davis, as Pat Deville, former love interest of the Mindhorn character, and the woman Thorncroft abandoned for fame, is great as usual, moving from wry amusement at his attempts to reconnect, to a sense of opportunities lost and lingering affection for a flawed man. Lastly, Tovey as “The Kestrel” moves seamlessly from threatening to childlike and back again, with plot revelations constantly shifting the audience’s perception of the character.
Mindhorn is a very enjoyable ninety minutes at the cinema. If you’re a fan of Barratt’s work on The Mighty Boosh and the melancholy Flowers, you’ll find a lot of comic gold in this new character. The plot is engaging, the cast are funny, and best of all it’s an original, non-franchise idea that deserves to be seen and enjoyed by as many people as possible.
Calum Maclean, 7 May 2017
This section: Calum Maclean – poet and aspiring writer, Cinema, What's On Glasgow West End: cinema, clubs, theatre, music, events, festivals, community and more
Related Pages
- Woodlands Anti-Racist Film Club – Dreamers (2025)
- The Old Oak, Screening Maryhill Burgh Halls
- “Murder, murder, polis, three stairs up!” An Evening in Taggart’s Glasgow
- Take 2: Flushed Away at GFT
- Carlton Jug Band – Avant Garde
- Author Talk With Ian Rankin
- Caroline Walker In Conversation at The Hunterian
- Anti-Racist Community Library – Woodlands Community Black History Month 2026
- CRER Black History Walking Tour – Black History Month October 2026
- Black History Month October 2026
- Specialist Tour | Black History Month: African Women, Myth and Material Memory
- Best Shot: How to Get Published with Sheila Wakefield
- Rip it Up at GFT
- Sense and Sensibility at GFT
- Le Bouchet at GFT
- Manhunter The Final Cut – 40th Anniversary at GFT
- Take 2: Barbie at GFT
- Children’s Walk for Gaza, Glasgow Green
- Black History Month 2026 at GFT
- Drawing The Past – Still Life, Shipbuilding
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.