Where You’re Meant To Be review by Calum Maclean

where yhou're meant to be image.jpg


Where You’re Meant To Be 

Directed by Paul Fegan 

Cast – Aidan Moffatt, Sheila Stewart

Running Time – 76 minutes

Due to be released on June 17, Where You’re Meant To Be is a funny and deeply poignant documentary exploring the conflict between tradition and innovation in the arts.  Through the efforts of former Arab Strap frontman Aidan Moffatt to update Scottish folk standards with modern uncensored lyrics, the film tells a story of transition, both positive and melancholy, while at the same time reintroducing the audience to the ballads of our ancestors and to the legacy of Sheila Stewart.


This film is wonderfully pitched between sadness and comedy, with Moffat’s narration, (directly addressed to Stewart and reflecting on mortality), nicely contrasted with his raconteur personality on the road.  Along with the viewer, Moffatt’s perspective on the old ballads is given a shake up from gleeful enjoyment in subverting the original lyrics to an awareness of the emotional resonance of these songs.  We see performances in town halls, fetes, kitchens and clubs, with singing ranging from the trained to the amateur, but the effect remains the same.  The film demonstrates the power in this music, evident with ancient or modern lyrics, through the reactions of listeners young and old, with hilarious, awkward, and often moving results.

The visual style is impressive throughout, with skilful use of archive footage woven through the narrative, expressive shots of rural landscapes transitioning into city night life, and some laugh out loud cut away reactions.  These editing and directorial choices really enhance the tonal shifts in Moffat’s adventure, leading to a rousing final act in Glasgow that manages to combine humour and emotion to great effect.


Where You’re Meant To Be is a unique viewing experience.  Well-paced and compelling throughout, this documentary highlights the expression of a disappearing way of life, while also making the case for new adaptations with wit and pathos.  Whichever side of the debate you fall on, be it Moffat’s, Stewart’s or a mutually appreciative common ground, this “funny wee film about music and death” is a gem and is not to be missed.

Calum Maclean, 29 May, 2016.

Where You’re Meant To Be will be screened in UK cinemas from 17 June. The cinema release will be accompanied by a live event tour, presenting Q&As and performances with Aidan Moffat and the film’s director and producer Paul Fegan.  whereyouremeanttobe.com

Almost Poetic: writing by Calum Maclean

West End Festival 2016: Hidden Lane Gallery, Masks,Music and Magic
Where You're Meant To Be GFT, 17 – 20 June, 2016

This section: Calum Maclean – poet and aspiring writer, Cinema, Film Reviews by Calum Maclean, What's On Glasgow West End: cinema, clubs, theatre, music, events, festivals, community and more

Written by :

Avatar of PatByrne Publisher of Pat's Guide to Glasgow West End; the community guide to the West End of Glasgow. Fiction and non-fiction writer.

Leave a Reply

Copyright Glasgow Westend 2009 thru 2017

Contact Pat's Guide to Glasgow West End | About Pat Byrne | Privacy Policy | Design by Jim Byrne Website Design